Email: mashti AT uwaterloo DOT ca (start subject line with CS350)
Rules
You will want to wait until you have covered the relevant lectures in
class.
Write a one page (no more than two) review of the paper covering the
questions below and any other problems or opportunities you think of
while reading the paper.
Schedule a meeting with Ali or one of the IAs to discuss the paper in
person (~15 minutes).
A good paper review will recieve a 3/5 or 4/5, while exceptional
reviews showing you went beyond the paper will recieve a 5/5. You can
go beyond the basic review by looking at related work, follow up papers
and thinking about further improvements in a space.
Due by the last day of class
Questions
What are the tools and ideas you should take away from the paper?
How have the assumptions changed because of time, technology, or
use?
Do the results/graphs cover everything you want to see? Anything
interesting regarding the results?
Is there any disconnect with the promise of the introduction and what is delivered?